SEATTLE - Anyone working for any length of time with vermiculite
insulation from a W.R. Grace & Co. mine in Montana faces a substantial
health risk from asbestos contamination, a federal health official warns.
The insulation was used in millions of homes and businesses nationwide. Testing of Zonolite brand insulation, along with Grace internal documents, "reveals that even minimal handling by workers or residents" exposes them
to
danger from asbestos, Dr. Hugh Sloan, an assistant U.S. surgeon general,
wrote in a memo last week.
His memo was a request for help from other federal health experts, the
Seattle Post-Intelligencer reported Monday.
Only two officials of Grace, based in Columbia, Md., could comment on the
memorandum and both were out of town Monday, company receptionists said.
Recent studies show even casual handling of the insulation can expose
workers or homeowners to 150 times the asbestos level considered safe
under
federal regulations, Sloan wrote in a memo to Linda Rosenstock, director
of
the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health.
Vermiculite from Grace's mine at Libby, Mont., was sold for use in garden
products, fireproofing, cement mixtures and more than a dozen other
consumer
products. The bulk of the ore was heated until it expanded like popcorn,
then marketed as Zonolite insulation.
Asbestos, linked to lung cancer and other diseases, is a natural
contaminant
of vermiculite ore. The Post-Intelligencer report involved vermiculite
specifically from the Libby mine, which Grace operated from 1963 to 1990.
Estimates of homes containing Zonolite insulation range from 2.5 million
to
16 million nationwide, the newspaper said.
The New York Times reported last month that the Environmental Protection
Agency was investigating why officials ignored for 18 years a study that
showed Grace was using ore laden with asbestos in insulation and other
building products.
The Post-Intelligencer said it had obtained internal documents showing
Grace
officials were aware of health risks from asbestos in insulation in the
1970s.
"We believe that a decision to affix asbestos warning labels to our
products
would result in substantial sales losses," executive vice president E.S.
Wood wrote on May 24, 1977, the newspaper reported. "The risk of liability
to customers is heightened by the decision not to label our products."
Federal investigators are conducting medical tests in the Libby area
following reports that hundreds of vermiculite miners and their relatives
have died or are dying from asbestos-related diseases. Several lawsuits
have been filed on behalf of workers and their families.
On Friday, Grace issued a statement acknowledging that some products made
in
the 1970s and '80s contained "minute quantities of naturally occurring
asbestos." The statement did not mention insulation.
Melanie A. Stone, MPH
Epidemiologist
Scientific Evidence, Inc.
08/14/00