Montana town makes emotional cry for help
LIBBY, Mont. -- No one can say, "Nobody told me" anymore.
Libby's "dirty little secret," as some victims call it, was aired with
fury, melancholy and fear Wednesday night before state and federal
health and environmental officials in the town gymnasium, packed
with almost 600 people, many of them carrying cylinders of oxygen
to augment breath shortened by damaged lungs. The topic of the
meeting was death. Death caused by the tremolite asbestos fibers
in the vermiculite ore miners took from nearby Zonolite Mountain for
decades. Death of parents and grandparents. The imminent death of
many of the people sitting on the hard metal chairs and wooden
bleachers. And -- in the most passionate speeches of a passionate
night -- the death that many fear is awaiting the children of Libby.
A Post-Intelligencer investigation last month revealed that at least
192 people have died of asbestos-related disease from the mine
near Libby, owned for 30 years by The W.R. Grace Co. At least
another 375 have been diagnosed with fatal disease. The P-I articles
also detailed how federal, state and local agencies had not stepped
forward to help the people of Libby, either denying knowledge of the
problem or pointing to other agencies for solutions.
Patrick Vinion told the crowd of his fears for his three children.
"In the local paper our health department says we only have 1
percent tremolite in our town. One percent of tremolite is not
acceptable no matter what anybody says," he yelled, slamming his
fist on the podium, the noise echoing through the gym like the blast
of a concussion grenade.
"One percent of tons of tremolite and I guarantee it will kill your
kids," he added in almost a whisper.
A woman in the bleachers, tightly hugging two young girls nestled
beside her, closed her eyes and shook her head.
Vinion anguished over the misinformation doled out to the miners
and the community over the years about the danger from the
pinkish ore that was supporting most of the town.
"When my father was a young man they told him, 'You can't eat
enough of that stuff. It won't bother you.' He's dead," he said.
"When I started getting sick when I was younger, they told me, 'You
never worked there. It's not possible. You can't get it that way.'
Well, it's more than possible. I'm dying of it."
Mark Simonich, the head of Montana's Department of Environmental
Quality, admitted that "mistakes were made" by state agencies in
the past. He urged the people to tell their stories, but to be polite.
They were, for the most part, but anger over what they saw as
betrayal by Grace, by the government and by some of the town's
physicians, was always close to the surface.
Terry Smith, who lost both of his parents to the asbestos, said he's
concerned that people are getting the wrong diagnoses from their
doctors.
Many of the people walking around town with oxygen bottles think
they have emphysema, he said.
He talked about his father and uncle both being told that their
breathing problems were from emphysema and that's what they
were being treated for.
"When my father died, they figured out it was asbestosis," Smith
said. "When my uncle died, they removed his lungs and they were
filled with asbestos.
"See a specialist. Find out what's really happening to you," he
implored.
Many in the audience nodded and cheered loudly in agreement.
The gathering was a fountain of emotion, with the fervor of a revival
meeting and the reverential embrace of an Irish wake.
Roger Sullivan, whose law firm represents many of the people in the
audience in their lawsuits against Grace, presented a detailed
history of the mine, which in its heyday produced 80 percent of the
world's vermiculite.
Using charts, maps and aerial photographs, he walked the
investigators and the townsfolk through Grace's own figures showing
how much asbestos was in the dust that escaped from the mine.
A litany of complex statistics and calculations, which might
normally set a crowd dozing, had people sitting on the edges of
their chairs.
He explained how the largest stack in the ore-processing mill was
spewing 10,000 pounds of asbestos each day, and how the wind
would disperse it over the town. He said the sparsely covered tailing
pile, given a clean bill of health by state investigators, still contains
5 billion pounds of asbestos.
Many in the crowd gasped when he projected a huge blowup of a
lethal tremolite fiber. Several people touched their chests. A couple
hugged their spouses.
Gayla Benefield lost her parents and was one of the few loud voices
telling any government official that she could buttonhole that the
health of Libby had to be studied.
She read a news clipping from the local paper, which quoted
Grace's manager for the mine cleanup, Alan Stringer, in glowing
detail about the "incredible" job that the company did in restoring
the mine to such a pristine condition that the Montana Mining
Association gave Grace an award of excellence. The article talked
of elk grazing in the lush grass and trees that Grace has planted.
"That's not what's up there," she said as she described the
towering, mostly barren, tailing pile and the nearby pond, which the
state admits are filled with asbestos dust.
"That's the dust which killed my dad. That's the dust that killed
mom. I don't want it to harm my children or grandchildren," she
said.
Stringer came from California to attend the meeting. He did not
speak.
A day earlier, Grace Chairman and CEO Paul Norris flew into
Helena with a bevy of lawyers and vice presidents to meet with the
governor. They told state officials that they would participate in the
Libby meeting. They didn't.
The presence of Grace officials in the state capitol did little to
comfort Bonnie Gestring of the Montana Environmental Information
Center. To the cheers of the crowd she called for an investigation of
"why Libby fell through the cracks."
"I can't believe so many have died before something happens. I can't
see how the laws could have been followed and people have been
hurt so terribly," she said angrily.
Norita Skramstad and her husband, Les, who both are dying from
asbestos-related disease, told the crowd:
"It is a death sentence. There is nothing you can do about it. Our
biggest concern now must be the children of this town. We don't
know if they have it and we must find out. This lies dormant and
then springs its ugly head up and it's full-blown."
Montanans usually hold their emotions pretty close to their vests.
Not here. Not at this meeting.
Grown men, many full-bearded, decked out in hunting caps and
heavy flannel shirts, gruff-looking loggers, miners and truck drivers,
wept without embarrassment.
One man, looking much older than his 60 years, pressed a plastic
oxygen mask to his face. Tears streamed down both sides.
"It's true. It's true. I know it, but this is the first time I've heard other
folk talk about it openly," he sobbed. His wife hugged him hard. "Let
him be," she said. "He'll be all right."
George Bauer, a Libby city councilman, wasn't surprised by the
tears.
"This is a close community that cares for each other and I think
people were surprised at what they heard," said Bauer, who has
held office for 24 years. "My eyes were opened. I had no idea of the
damage that was done."
He wasn't alone.
Even the professionals, those who deal with health and
environmental disasters, appeared shaken.
Across the gym, in the corner of the bleachers, sat Paul Peronard,
EPA's on-scene coordinator, and his team of toxicologists, medical
coordinator and public relations specialist.
The plight of the people, Peronard said, made him feel like
"someone had ripped the lining of my stomach out."
"I can't tell you how bad I feel for these people. Everybody has failed
them up to this point and I'm going to make sure that stops. We've
got to do right by these people." He reflected on other cleanup sites
to which his team has responded.
"We talk about possible risks, people who might get ill in the future
or in very serious cases might die. Here in Libby, they've already
died and many, many more are dying. We've never seen anything
like this. I can understand why some of these people are terrified."
Libby's mayor, Tony Berget, said the meeting did little to lessen the
anger in the town.
"There is still a split in the town. A lot of people think Grace was
good for the community, treated us well and did nothing wrong," the
mayor said. "Others are worried about real estate sales and
Christmas buying."
Don Judge, the head of the Montana AFL-CIO, told the crowd he'd
just returned from Seattle and the World Trade Organization
meeting. He said he heard delegates from France say they wanted
to ban the importation of asbestos products into their country, and
heard Canadian representatives say they want to sell their asbestos
everywhere.
"Do they know about, Libby, Montana? Do they know about the
miners and spouses and children of Libby, Montana? Do they
understand that they're transporting this white death all across the
world?"
With embarrassment obvious in his tone, the union leader
apologized for the AFL-CIO's lack of knowledge and assistance.
"We didn't understand what was happening," Judge said. "We knew
that people had good jobs and good benefits and the community of
Libby was thriving because of it. Only after the plant was shut down
did we understand the extent of what had been foisted upon the
workers in this community, their spouses and children."
Judge worried about what the children must think.
"They would be frightened to death that they were going to suffer
like their grandparents, their uncles and their fathers. The
government has the responsibility to those kids to make sure this
town is clean. We're going to ride somebody's ass to make sure it's
done.
"The children need to understand that they will be free to breathe
the air, to drink the water, to even play on the streets of this
community. They need to understand that so they can go back to
being kids."
12/03/99